.jpg)
Introduction
For SMEs doing business with the Chinese market, safeguarding intellectual property (IP), especially patents, is crucial. China operates on a first-to-file system, meaning that without proactive legal protections, businesses risk patent theft, infringement, and competitive disadvantages.
This guide covers the Chinese patent system, common infringement scenarios, litigation strategies, and best practices to help SMEs protect their patents when outsourcing manufacturing, entering joint ventures, or selling products in China.
Why Patent Protection is Critical for SMEs in China
Many SMEs mistakenly assume that securing a patent in their home country automatically protects them in China. However, patents are territorial, meaning you must file in China separately to gain protection. Here’s why patent protection is essential:
- Prevent Patent Theft & Reverse Engineering: Manufacturing partners may attempt to replicate patented technology if safeguards are not in place.
- Avoid Competitor Infringement: Without registration, third parties can legally register your invention in China and block your sales.
- Stronger Legal Standing: Patent enforcement is easier when rights are officially recognized under China’s Patent Law.
- Maximize Commercialization Opportunities: Secure licensing deals and joint ventures with confidence.
High-risk Sectors
SMEs involved in the following sectors should be particularly attentive to patent protection when doing business with China:
Technology and Electronics
High-tech innovations are susceptible to replication, making it crucial for companies in this sector to secure patents to prevent unauthorized use and maintain a competitive advantage.
Pharmaceuticals and Biotechnology
Proprietary formulations and processes require stringent protection due to the high investment in research and development and the potential for significant financial loss if infringed upon.
Manufacturing and Engineering
Unique machinery designs and manufacturing processes are valuable assets that, if not protected, can be copied, leading to loss of market share and revenue.
Consumer Products
Innovative designs and functionalities in consumer goods can be easily imitated, diluting brand value and affecting profitability.
Engaging in activities such as outsourcing manufacturing, forming joint ventures, or establishing subsidiaries in China can expose companies to patent infringement or theft if proper precautions are not taken.
Understanding China’s Patent System
China’s patent protection is governed by the Patent Law of the People’s Republic of China, administered by the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA).
A. Types of Patents
China's patent system consists of three main categories:
- Invention Patents (20 years) – Protects new products, methods, or improvements.
- Utility Model Patents (10 years) – Covers minor technical innovations and improvements.
- Design Patents (15 years) – Protects visual designs of products.
B. Key Differences: China vs. U.S.
- Patent System: China (First-to-file) vs. U.S. (First-to-invent)
- Patent Duration: China (10-20 years) vs. U.S. (15-20 years)
- Grace Period for Public Disclosure: China (No grace period) vs. U.S. (12-month grace period)
Takeaway
SMEs must file early in China to avoid patent hijacking.
Steps to Protect Patents in China
1. Conduct Thorough Patent Searches
Before filing for a patent in China, SMEs should conduct a comprehensive patent search to ensure their invention is unique within the Chinese market. This helps avoid infringement claims and ensures that the patent application is strong.
- Use Official Databases: Utilize resources such as the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) to search for existing patents.
- Prior Art Searches: Conduct prior art searches to determine if similar patents exist.
- Local Expertise: Work with a local patent attorney to assess the novelty of your invention.
2. Timely Patent Filing
Due to China's first-to-file system, it is critical to file patents as soon as possible. Delays can result in competitors registering a similar patent first, potentially blocking you from using your own invention in China.
- International Protection: If you already have a patent in another country, file under the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) to secure international protection.
- Utility Model Patents: SMEs should also consider filing utility model patents for quicker approval.
3. Utilize Local Expertise
Navigating China's patent system can be complex. Partnering with local IP attorneys can help:
- Accurate Translation: Ensure proper translation of patent applications.
- Legal Nuances: Address legal nuances specific to China.
- Administrative Procedures: Navigate the CNIPA’s administrative procedures efficiently.
4. Monitor and Enforce Rights
Regular monitoring of the market is essential to detect patent infringement. SMEs should:
- Market Surveillance: Set up alerts for unauthorized use of their patented products.
- Legal Enforcement: Work with Chinese legal teams to enforce patent rights.
- Administrative Measures: Consider using administrative enforcement measures such as CNIPA’s patent infringement procedures.
Common Patent Infringement Scenarios and Prevention Strategies
Understanding potential scenarios where patent infringement may occur is crucial for SMEs operating in or with China. Below are common situations and strategies to prevent infringement:
1. Joint Ventures
Scenario: An SME forms a joint venture with a Chinese company to develop or manufacture products. There's a risk that the partner may use the SME's patented technology beyond the agreed scope or after the partnership ends.
Prevention Strategies:
- Detailed Agreements: Clearly define the scope of use for each party's patents in the joint venture agreement. Specify permitted and prohibited uses to prevent unauthorized exploitation.
- Ownership Clauses: Establish clear ownership of any jointly developed IP. Determine whether new inventions are jointly owned or belong to one party, and outline rights to use and license these inventions.
- Exit Provisions: Include clauses that address the handling of IP rights upon termination of the joint venture. Specify whether licenses are revoked or continue post-termination.
2. Licensing Agreements
Scenario: An SME licenses its patented technology to a Chinese manufacturer for production. Without proper safeguards, the manufacturer may use the technology beyond the agreed terms, including producing additional unauthorized units or selling the technology to competitors.
Prevention Strategies:
- Tightly Defined Licensing Agreements: Clearly define the scope of use, production limitations, and duration of the license.
- Regular Audits: Conduct regular inspections and audits to ensure compliance with licensing terms.
- IP Clause Enforcement: Ensure that breach of IP terms results in substantial penalties or termination of the agreement.
3. Selling Products in China
Scenario: An SME sells its patented product in China, only to find that competitors reverse-engineer the product and create counterfeit versions.
Prevention Strategies:
- Trade Secret Protection: Use encryption, watermarking, or security features to protect sensitive designs.
- Aggressive Enforcement: Monitor Chinese markets and e-commerce platforms to identify counterfeit products and take action.
- Customs Registration: Register patents with Chinese customs to block counterfeit goods from being exported or imported.
Patent Enforcement & Litigation in China
Protecting patents in China requires a clear understanding of legal enforcement mechanisms, the court system, and alternative dispute resolution channels. Below is a structured approach to enforcing patent rights in China.
A. Types of Patent Enforcement Mechanisms
Patent owners have multiple avenues to enforce their rights in China:
- Civil Litigation – Filing a lawsuit in court against an infringer for damages or injunctions.
- Patent Invalidity Proceedings – A legal challenge to revoke a granted patent if it lacks novelty or violates legal criteria.
- Administrative Complaints (CNIPA & SAMR) – Filing complaints with regulatory authorities for faster action against infringers.
- Criminal Enforcement (Public Security Bureau, PSB) – Pursuing criminal charges for severe infringement cases.
- Customs Border Protection (General Administration of Customs, GACC) – Blocking the import/export of infringing goods.
Each enforcement path serves different purposes, and SMEs must choose the most effective and practical approach based on the severity of infringement.
B. Court System & Jurisdictions for Patent Disputes
Patent-related disputes in China are handled by specialized courts that focus on IP enforcement:
- Intermediate People’s Courts and IP Courts – Handle first-instance patent infringement cases.
- Beijing Intellectual Property Court – Oversees appeals related to CNIPA patent validity decisions.
- Supreme People’s Court (SPC) IP Tribunal – The highest appeal body for patent disputes.
- Internet Courts – Handle cases related to online patent, trademark, and copyright violations.
Knowing the right court to file in is essential for speeding up enforcement and maximizing legal protection.
C. Bifurcation of Patent Proceedings
Unlike some jurisdictions, China separates patent validity from infringement litigation, meaning:
- Patent validity challenges are handled by CNIPA, and appeals go to the Beijing IP Court.
- Patent infringement claims (damages or injunctions) are handled in civil courts.
This means that even if an SME files a patent infringement lawsuit, the accused party can challenge the patent’s validity separately through CNIPA, delaying or complicating enforcement.
D. Injunctions & Legal Remedies
1. Interim Injunctions – Courts grant temporary injunctions to prevent ongoing infringement if the patent holder can prove:
- Immediate and irreparable harm to their business.
- High likelihood of infringement based on preliminary evidence.
- Provision of a security bond to compensate the defendant in case of wrongful injunction.
2. Permanent Injunctions – If infringement is proven, courts typically grant permanent injunctions unless:
- The public interest would be severely affected.
- The patent is related to Standard Essential Patents (SEPs), where mandatory licensing rules may apply.
E. Patent Infringement Enforcement Options
SMEs can choose different routes to combat infringement based on cost, speed, and severity:
- Civil Litigation – Ideal for high-value infringement cases where damages are substantial.
- Administrative Complaints via SAMR – Useful for stopping small-scale infringements quickly but does not award damages.
- Criminal Enforcement via PSB – Reserved for serious, large-scale commercial infringement.
F. Customs Border Protection for Patents
To prevent infringing products from leaving or entering China, SMEs can register patents with China Customs (GACC):
- Customs officers intercept infringing goods based on registered IP rights.
- If infringement is confirmed, the goods may be:
- Confiscated or destroyed if modifications are impossible.
- Auctioned after infringing elements are removed.
- A security bond must be paid by the patent holder to initiate enforcement.
Practical Tips for SMEs Protecting Patents in China
- File for Patent Protection Before Disclosure – Any public exposure (trade shows, prototypes, supplier demos) before filing can make patents ineligible for protection in China.
- Use Watermarking & Digital Protections – If sharing sensitive designs, use encrypted files, digital watermarks, and restricted access permissions.
- Monitor the CNIPA Database for Competing Patents – Competitors may attempt to file patents similar to yours; contest these early.
- Work with Local Legal Experts – Chinese patent law is complex and highly procedural. A China-based IP lawyer significantly improves your chances of success in infringement cases.
Conclusion
Securing patent protection in China requires proactive legal filings, careful IP management, and vigilant enforcement. By implementing robust patent strategies, SMEs can protect their innovations, minimize infringement risks, and maximize their market potential in China.
Let's Solve Your Problem Today.
👈 Connect with Trusted Legal Experts, get a free quote, and handle your legal matters—all from the comfort of your home.
Other Resources:
- China NNN Agreement: A Must-Have for IP Protection in China
- How to Protect Your Intellectual Property in China: 2024 Guide for Tech SMEs
- Outsourcing to China - Best Practices for SMEs to Avoid Scams and Protect IP
Other Services:
💡 Don't know where to start? Contact the Trustiics Concierge.